Calling out the Perennial Negative peddlers : Piyush Goyal

Published By : Admin | September 17, 2023 | 10:21 IST

PM Modi has broken many stereotypes and many opinions. His tenure is an example of calling out the shams and silencing his critics through immense hard work and commitment for the cause of our nation.

There has been a concerted effort for the past two decades by a section of self-anointed thinkers to defame Prime Minister Narendra Modi. A section of the Indian and foreign media is also known for its bias against PM Modi. From personal attacks to policy disparagements without any logic, he has faced it all. But true to his working style, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has always worked hard and proved their fake charges wrong.

The tragedy has been that that the dislike of this section of the old regime for PM Modi often translates to hating the vision of Bharat itself. Even rightly using the word ‘Bharat’ instead of ‘India’ made them accuse PM Modi of renaming India. Logic derides these hordes, for Bharat has the imprimatur of the Constitution as well.

However, Prime Minister Modi has shattered every fake or manufactured narrative set against him. Though in the last two decades scores of such narratives have been propagated and then conclusively demolished, for the purpose of this article, let us examine just five myths that PM Modi has broken.


First, that PM Modi is not up to the task to meet the G20 leadership summit challenge in a complex world.

The latest obsession of the ancient regime observers was preconceived notions of G20 failure, as if they were praying for the government to fail on the global stage. They thought that in a polarised world, India under PM Modi leadership would not be able to produce any positive outcomes. The absence of Xi Jinping and Vladmir Putin further added to their comfort. Secretly raising toasts for failure and casting aspersions on the success of India’s G20 Presidency was their job until a few days ago.

While on the one hand, The Guardian’s pessimism was adverting of the end of globalisation; on the other hand, the Washington Post was predicting bad weather for the G20. France 24 too forecasted a sea of troubles for India’s G20 Presidency.

But despite the naysayers’ prophecy of doomsday for the G20, the outcome has clearly silenced them all. The New Delhi Leaders’ Summit Declaration was adopted in a remarkable breakthrough under PM Modi’s leadership, as all the members of the G20 reached consensus on the opening day of the summit itself. The New Delhi Declaration, running into 83 paragraphs, was adopted with “100% consensus on all developmental and geo-political issues without any footnotes or marginalia in the text”. It was a big achievement in the times of a multipolar world that the message of “One Earth, One Family, One Future” echoed amongst all the countries.

Similarly, there were questions about India’s commitment to the cause of the Global South. Yet by helping the African Union join the ranks of the G20, India has not only emerged as a champion of the Global South, but it has also strengthened India’s position at the global stage.

But the G20 historic success is not just one-off. Associated with it, let’s examine the second myth, that PM Modi is generally not adept at foreign policy and would flounder when faced with a difficult situation.

In the Russia-Ukraine conflict, India consistently stressed the significance of all concerned parties engaging in constructive dialogue to seek a resolution that safeguards sovereignty and upholds global norms. India has resolutely maintained its autonomy over strategic decisions throughout this war. Probably India is one of the few countries that is heard both in Russia and in Ukraine. In fact, PM Modi’s formulation of “Today’s era must not be of war” has become the global buzzword.

Similarly, the way PM Modi has managed the Middle East foreign policy is nothing short of remarkable. It is one foreign policy area where self-proclaimed experts, who mocked the Prime Minister, had given up as an unattainable goal. But what was unattainable for the ‘experts’ has been made possible by PM Modi as the just concluded India- Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor testifies.

This is neither the first nor the last time that PM Modi has outdone himself. His decision-making and leadership qualities would soon feature in B school’s syllabus. He is adept at converting difficult situations into remarkable opportunities. His policies, which were initially criticised, have been proven to have a far-reaching positive impact on India.

Third, that PM Modi does not understand economic policy and would therefore be unable to deliver.

One of the biggest examples of the naysayers’ doubting PM Modi is when the Jan Dhan Yojana was launched. Many critiqued the financial inclusion initiative; some even went so far as to call it ‘populism gone berserk’.

But only a myopic understanding of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s policies could have led to such conclusions. Today, the policy initiative of the Jan Dhan Yojana is instrumental in ensuring financial inclusion for all. By banking the unbanked, this scheme has catapulted Bharat from its financial inclusion rate of mere 25% in 2008 to over 80% of adults by 2022. This is such a remarkable achievement that now the World Bank has advocated it as a model worth emulating for other countries. As of date, over 50 crore Jan Dhan bank accounts have been opened, of which 27 crore are financially empowered women. This has resulted in mass social revolution in India is and another feather in the cap of PM Modi.

But consider what PM Modi did with Jan Dhan Yojana subsequent to every poor getting a bank account. The Aadhar enrolment, providing every person a unique identification number, earlier mired in intra-government turf wars during the Congress regime, picked up pace after 2014 and was linked to bank accounts. This ensured Direct Benefit Transfers (DBT) to beneficiaries by avoiding leakages by eliminating middlemen and corruption. Till date, about Rs.2.3 lakh crore of savings have been ensured by direct transfers of over Rs.31 lakh crores through DBT. It demolished the Congress’ theory which assumed that out of every 1 rupee spent, only 15 paise could reach the poor. Now the adage is “one rupee spent; one-rupee benefits for the poor”.

No one can forget the jibes about GST, but “One Nation, One Tax” has formalised the Indian economy like never before and is truly a game changer.

Fourth, PM Modi’s vision of Digital Public Infrastructure (DPI) and his belief that Digital can transform the lives of the poor.

Many so-called experts, speaking in clipped accent, mocked PM Modi’s vision to promote a digital economy. Citing the example of the poor vegetable seller, a well-known politician even questioned the very wisdom of going digital and banking on mobile connectivity when he said “there is neither infrastructure to charge the mobiles nor the education for the poor to use digital”. Now our heart swells with pride when the German Minister uses UPI to make payment to a vegetable vendor. In the last 7 years, India, under PM Modi, we have succeeded in creating an ecosystem that has made India a world leader in digital payments. Indeed, India’s model of DPI has become a model for the world to emulate. Digital is in fact one space where PM Modi has been a transformative visionary.

Fifth, PM Modi’s ability to handle the complex challenge posed by the COVID-19 pandemic – both on the health front, as well as the economic front.

There were many obituaries written about the Indian economy during COVID. Few even suggested discarding fiscal schedule since India was in a lockdown. Many insisted on managing the COVID impact by recklessly increasing the supply of money, a model followed by many Western countries. But the government recognised the negative impact it would have on the economy. The easy path was shunned for a more difficult yet pragmatic approach to dealing with the COVID economic crisis.

PM Modi ensured, through pragmatic policies and proactive actions that the Indian economy not only survived the onslaught of COVID but also became the ‘World’s Bright Spot’. We are today not only the world’s fastest growing, large economy but have also managed to keep inflation at moderate levels. No other major democracy has been able to manage this feat.

PM Modi has broken many stereotypes and many opinions. His tenure is an example of calling out the shams and silencing his critics through immense hard work and commitment for the cause of our nation. He remains the loved and respected Pradhan Sewak of Bharat.

 

Explore More
ശ്രീരാമജന്മഭൂമി ക്ഷേത്രത്തിലെ പതാക ഉയർത്തൽ ഉത്സവത്തിനിടെ പ്രധാനമന്ത്രി നടത്തിയ പ്രസം​ഗം

ജനപ്രിയ പ്രസംഗങ്ങൾ

ശ്രീരാമജന്മഭൂമി ക്ഷേത്രത്തിലെ പതാക ഉയർത്തൽ ഉത്സവത്തിനിടെ പ്രധാനമന്ത്രി നടത്തിയ പ്രസം​ഗം
India remains among best-performing major economies: S&P Global

Media Coverage

India remains among best-performing major economies: S&P Global
NM on the go

Nm on the go

Always be the first to hear from the PM. Get the App Now!
...
Narendra Modi is a leader beyond ceremony
February 28, 2026

Force of habit, maybe. Or just the low-grade anxiety that comes with handing something to the prime minister of 1.4 billion people and hoping it works. I scribbled a quick line on the corner of my notepad, confirmed the ink was flowing, and handed it over.

He took it without looking at the pen. He was looking at me.

That was the first thing I noticed about Narendra Modi up close. The eye contact. Steady, unhurried, the kind that makes you feel like the meeting isn’t scheduled. He greeted me standing, which I hadn’t expected, and when he shook my hand, the grip was firm, and it lasted a beat longer than these things usually do. Just deliberate. Like he wanted you to know he meant it.

He apologized for the wait. The Israeli security detail outside his King David suite had put me through more checks than I care to describe. At one point, I was fairly certain I was going to be turned away despite holding a personal invitation from the man himself, which would have made for an interesting column but a frustrating afternoon.

Modi had heard about the delay and said sorry before anything else. I told him it was the Israeli side causing the trouble, not his team. He smiled. The room loosened slightly.

Then he picked up the special front page we had published for his visit, looked at it for a moment, and wrote in Hindi, standing, without sitting down or making any ceremony out of it. Two lines: “Humanity will remain supreme. Democracy will remain eternal.”

He signed his name and dated it February 26, 2026. The whole thing took maybe 45 seconds. He handed the page back with both hands.

I’ve interviewed a lot of people while in this job. Politicians, presidents, religious leaders, celebrities. There is a type of public figure who has spent so many years being watched that everything they do has become a kind of performance. The handshake, the pause, the practiced sincerity. Modi wasn’t that. Whatever he was doing in that suite, he was just there, fully, in a way that is rarer than it sounds.

Through a translator, you could still hear the rhythm of how he thinks. Complete thoughts. Real pauses, not to buy time, but because he’s actually considering what you said.

At one point, I told him his Knesset speech – delivered the day before, the first ever by an Indian prime minister to Israel’s parliament – felt historic. He received it simply, without deflecting or inflating it, and then said something that stayed with me: “Our nations and religions are a lot more similar than what people think.”

He had spent the previous day making exactly that case. Not as a diplomatic courtesy. As a philosophical argument.

Most leaders who come to Jerusalem talk about security, trade, and technology. Modi did that, too, and then he went somewhere else entirely. He gave what I can only describe as a civilizational speech, one that asked a genuinely interesting question: What happens when two of the world’s oldest living cultures finally look at each other carefully and recognize something familiar?

Tikkun Olam and Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam

HIS ANSWER was built on a comparison that sounds simple until you think about it. He placed Tikkun Olam (the Jewish concept of repairing and healing the world) next to Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam (the ancient Sanskrit declaration that the world is one family). He compared Halacha (Jewish law as the living framework for daily ethical conduct) to dharma (the Hindu concept of moral order and personal duty).

What he was pointing at is that both civilizations solved the same problem in remarkably similar ways. How do you build a society where ethics isn’t a sermon delivered on a holy day but a practice embedded in the texture of ordinary life? Both Judaism and Hinduism answered: Through law, through duty, through the 10,000 small decisions that make up a day.

This is not a coincidence that gets discovered at diplomatic summits. It is a structural similarity, centuries deep.

For a reader of hassidic thought, this lands with particular force. Hassidism (Hassidut, or hassidic teaching and philosophy) calls this avodah (literally “work,” meaning inner spiritual intention expressed through practical deeds).

The Baal Shem Tov, the 18th-century founder of Hassidut, taught that the divine is found not in retreat from the world but in full engagement with it, in the marketplace, at the table, in the way you treat the person standing in front of you. Modi, without using that language, was honoring exactly that tradition and pointing out that India built its civilization on the same foundation.

He connected Hanukkah and Diwali (the Hindu festival of lights, celebrating the victory of light over darkness), and the pairing is more than poetic.

Both festivals reject the passive response to darkness. In the Hanukkah story, the rabbis made a specific decision: The mitzvah (religious commandment) is not to light a large fire but to add one small candle each night, incrementally, publicly, stubbornly. That is a philosophy of historical action. Darkness is not defeated all at once. It is pushed back by accumulated small acts of light.

Diwali carries the same logic, rows of diyas (small clay oil lamps) lit across millions of homes, each one a separate act that adds to a larger illumination.

He paired Purim with Holi (the Hindu spring festival, marking the triumph of good over evil), and here, too, the intellectual connection runs even deeper. Both holidays are built on the experience of hiddenness suddenly reversed.

In the Purim story, God’s name never appears in the Book of Esther. The miracle is concealed inside what looks like ordinary palace politics and human decision-making. Hassidic thought reads this as the deepest kind of truth: that providence (hashgacha pratit, divine guidance in the details of individual lives) often looks, from the outside, like coincidence or history. You only see the pattern when you’re willing to look for it.

Modi’s insistence on ancient connections between India and Israel, on trade routes and shared texts, and a Persian queen named Esther, whose Hebrew name connects to the Hebrew word for “hidden,” carries the same idea. Some relationships are written into history long before the diplomats arrive to formalize them.

HE SPOKE about terrorism plainly, without softening the language. He linked the October 7 massacre to the Mumbai attacks, India’s own wound, still felt. He said no cause justifies the murder of civilians. He said terrorism anywhere threatens peace everywhere. He said it the way people say things they’ve believed for a long time and have stopped needing to rehearse.

Then he did something that moved the room more than any of the formal declarations. He singled out the Indian workers and caregivers who were in Israel on October 7, 2023. People who stayed. Who helped. Who didn’t run. He quoted the Talmud: Whoever saves one life saves an entire world.

In hassidic terms, this was the speech’s most important moment. Hassidut puts enormous weight on the deed that looks small but carries cosmic significance, the nitzotz (spark of holiness) hidden inside the ordinary act, waiting to be elevated by the person who chooses to do it anyway.

He took foreign workers in a war zone and made them the moral center of the relationship between two nations. That is not rhetoric. That is a worldview that knows where to look for what matters.

He also said something that Israel’s friends don’t always say out loud. Jewish communities lived in India for centuries, he told the Knesset, without persecution, without fear, without having to hide who they were. They preserved their faith and participated fully in society. He called it a source of pride for India.

He was right to call it that, and he was right to say it in Jerusalem in 2026, when the question of where in the world Jewish life can be lived openly has rarely felt more urgent.

Back in the suite, the conversation was warm. He has the quality of making a scheduled meeting feel like an actual conversation. When I told him the Knesset speech felt historic, he returned to the same idea he’d opened with: that the two civilizations are more similar than most people realize. He said it like someone reporting back from a conclusion he’d reached a long time ago and finally found the right room to say it in.

Our Wednesday cover had already been moving fast across social media before I walked into that suite. Modi reposted it to his enormous following on X/Twitter. Indian media picked it up. A front page can travel like that now, faster than anything you write underneath it.

The two handwritten lines are something else. They sit on paper, in a hotel room in Jerusalem, written standing up by a man who didn’t need to write anything and chose to write that. Humanity first. Democracy is permanent. One Hanukkah candle, one diya, same dark night, same instinct to keep adding light to it one careful flame at a time.

I tested the pen before I gave it to him.

Turns out he didn’t need my help.

(Mr. Zvika Klein is the Jerusalem Post Editor-in-Chief. The views expressed are personal.)

Source: The Jerusalem Post